Monday, Sep. 29, 1947

Bad Throw

GRENADINE ETCHING (270 pp.)--Robert C. Ruark--Doubleday ($2.75).

Grenadine Etching is a lampoon on the big-bosomed heroines of lending-library historical fiction--seemingly a sure-fire subject. The author, a Scripps-Howard columnist, must have thought so, because he didn't work hard enough at it.

Grenadine's father was believed to be "the bastard son of an English King who had despoiled a Scottish maid between the act of shooting grouse and angling for landlocked salmon." Grenadine, herself part Negro with Creole trimmings, grows up with a gorilla for a playmate; her first word, at seven months, is "man." She marries the governor of Havana, then becomes a slave trader, millionaire racehorse owner, inventor of the cigaret and, after the first 100 pages, dull to read about. Merely exaggerating the absurd is no sure way to hilarity; satire must make its own kind of sense and this makes little or none. Readers will admire Ruark's choice of target but deplore his aim.

This file is automatically generated by a robot program, so reader's discretion is required.